Square Payroll vs Paycom in April 2026

87% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more

Square Payroll

Payroll Software

4.7 200 user ratings

View Details

97% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more

Paycom

Payroll Software

4.4 3,568 user ratings

View Details

Featured

89% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more

Papaya Global

Payroll Software

4.5 49 user ratings

Visit Website

Overview

Description	Square Payroll is an all-in-one employee payment solution that works with every type of business. It allows employers to pay employees and contractors monthly or at an hourly rate, offer health and other benefits, pay teams on the go with an available mobile app. With Square Payroll, employee payment is possible with just a few steps, all that is required is to: enter business information, add team/employee list and finally, run the payroll. The software even takes care of tax fillings and withholdings. The solution syncs your time card and POS to help calculate and distribute wages to your employees and can even help to calculate credit card tips processed by Square…... all in one click. Square Payroll also allows you to offer benefits like health insurance, 401(K) and more to your employees. All you have to do is choose the benefits that fit your needs and budgets. Payroll can be run from mobile devices via the Square Payroll App to pay employees on the go. Read more	Paycom is a comprehensive HR and Payroll tool that allows users to transform their workplace using a single database. With the Talent Acquisition tools, users can easily find, hire, and onboard the right candidates seamlessly. The Applicant Tracking feature enables users to post to thousands of job boards at once and also filters out non-qualified applicants. It scans more than 300 million criminal records and also allows new hires to self-onboard. Through the Performance Management tool, employees can review themselves including their managers. The employers can also align the goals of employees with those of the organization. It ensures easy payroll management where employees are paid accurately and on-time, making the whole system of the organization run smoothly. The software is designed to allow managers to complete important tasks from anywhere and handle submissions, editing, and approval of working hours online. It eliminates the process of data re-entry and comes with easy customization and search options. Read more	A payroll suite for businesses. Papaya Global is a cloud-based payroll management software that helps multinational businesses manage worldwide payroll, international payments, and contractors. The software comprises vital features, including data security, cost breakdown analysis, records management, and benefits administration. Using a party EoR (employer of record), this software helps users streamline recruiting in multiple duplications and countries and manage payments and classification for foreign and domestic contract workers. This integrated platform provides tools for managing, recruiting, and onboarding when employees are in edge-to-edge solutions. Moreover, Papaya Global alerts the country and staff members for documentation when the review is required. Additionally, managers can automate payroll processes in various currencies and analyze workforce spending on a centralized dashboard. And through a secure portal, workers can attain their payment receipt in their native language. This software allows business teams to meet in compliance by storing employee invoices, documents, forms, and report formats according to the needs of each jurisdiction or country. Papaya Global software follows subscription-based and quotation-based pricing strategies under Payroll, Global, Eor, Contractor Management, And Parallel Intelligence Suite Plans. Read more
Pricing Options	Free Trial Available Starts at $35.00.	Free Trial Not Available Offers Custom plan.	Free Trial Not Available Starts at $2.50.
SW Score & Breakdown	87% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 96% Reviews 77% Momentum 67% Popularity 67%	97% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 99% Reviews 99% Momentum 71% Popularity 97%	89% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 100% Reviews 80% Momentum 64% Popularity 81%
SaaSworthy Awards	Not Available	# 1 Most Worthy # 1 Highly Rated	Not Available

Features

Total Features	13 Features	15 Features	17 Features
Common Features for All	Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form EOR Services Facilitates the management of employment-related responsibilities, compliance, and HR functions associated with Employer of Record (EOR) services Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-Currency Enables payment and collection in multiple currencies. PEO Services Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs) offer small and medium-sized businesses affordable HR services and benefits by serving as co-employers and managing compliance, eliminating the need for an in-house HR department. Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Filing Allows the filing of payroll tax forms for federal, state, and local taxes. W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 8 More - Show Less	Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form EOR Services Facilitates the management of employment-related responsibilities, compliance, and HR functions associated with Employer of Record (EOR) services Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-Currency Enables payment and collection in multiple currencies. PEO Services Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs) offer small and medium-sized businesses affordable HR services and benefits by serving as co-employers and managing compliance, eliminating the need for an in-house HR department. Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Filing Allows the filing of payroll tax forms for federal, state, and local taxes. W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 9 More - Show Less	Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form EOR Services Facilitates the management of employment-related responsibilities, compliance, and HR functions associated with Employer of Record (EOR) services Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-Currency Enables payment and collection in multiple currencies. PEO Services Professional Employer Organizations (PEOs) offer small and medium-sized businesses affordable HR services and benefits by serving as co-employers and managing compliance, eliminating the need for an in-house HR department. Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Filing Allows the filing of payroll tax forms for federal, state, and local taxes. W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 11 More - Show Less
Unique Features	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time

Technical Details

Organization Types Supported	Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business	Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business	Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business
Platforms Supported	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS
Modes of Support	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online
API Support	Available	NA	NA

Reviews & Ratings

User Rating	4.7/5 200 user ratings	4.4/5 3,568 user ratings	4.5/5 49 user ratings
Rating Distribution	Excellent 78.5% Very Good 14.5% Average 4% Poor 0.5% Terrible 2.5%	Excellent 64.1% Very Good 21.8% Average 5.6% Poor 2.2% Terrible 6.3%	Excellent 77.6% Very Good 10.2% Average 4.1% Poor 2% Terrible 6.1%
User Sentiments	Not Available	User-friendly Interface, Comprehensive Payroll Features, Robust Reporting Capabilities, Excellent Customer Support Inconsistent Customer Support, Complicated Benefit Enrollment Process, Time Clock Issues, Difficult System Navigation	Not Available
Review Summary	Not Available	Overall, users praise Paycom's user-friendly interface, comprehensive features, and excellent customer support. It is lauded for its ease of use, allowing even non-technical users to navigate seamlessly. The payroll processing capabilities are highly regarded for their accuracy and efficiency. Additionally, the reporting and analytics features are deemed valuable in providing insights into employee data and making informed decisions. However, some negative feedback mentions occasional technical glitches and a need for more customization options.	Not Available
	Read All User Reviews	Read All User Reviews	Read All User Reviews

AI-Generated from the text of User Reviews

Pricing

Pricing Options	Free Trial Available Starts at $35.00.	Free Trial Not Available Offers Custom plan.	Free Trial Not Available Starts at $2.50.
Pricing Plans Monthly Plans Annual Plans	Full-service payroll $35.00 $35.00 per month	Paycom Custom	Grow Global (Payroll Plus) $25.00 $25.00 per user / month Scale Global (Payroll Plus) $20.00 $20.00 per user / month Enterprise Global (Payroll Plus) $15.00 $15.00 per user / month Enterprise Grade EOR $599.00 $599.00 per user / month Contractor Payments and Management $30.00 $30.00 per user / month Global workforce payments $2.50 $2.50 per Transcation Agent of Record $200.00 $200.00 per user / month
	View Detailed Pricing	View Detailed Pricing	View Detailed Pricing

Have Questions? We can help!

Get personalized recommendations from our experts on call

✔ Trusted by more than 5 Million users across the globe.

Alternatives

	Paychex Flex 3.8 3,053 ratings Square Payroll Vs Paychex Flex QuickBooks Payroll 4.4 626 ratings Square Payroll Vs QuickBooks Payroll Paybooks 4.7 35 ratings Square Payroll Vs Paybooks RUN Powered by ADP 4.5 3,061 ratings Square Payroll Vs RUN Powered by ADP ADP Payroll Services 4.2 226 ratings	Paylocity 4.3 3,454 ratings Paycom Vs Paylocity ADP Workforce Now 4.3 2,560 ratings Paychex Flex 3.8 3,053 ratings Paycom Vs Paychex Flex Paycor 4.1 863 ratings SumoPayroll 3.9 10 ratings Paycom Vs SumoPayroll
	View All Square Payroll Alternatives	View All Paycom Alternatives